Can You Put Parchment Paper in a Toaster Oven?

The cookie batter looks great, with those organic chocolate chips calling your name. The kitchen oven is busy roasting that leg of lamb for dinner, so you decide to use the toaster oven for the cookies. But can you put parchment paper in a toaster oven? Or will it burst into flames?

Can You Put Parchment Paper in a Toaster Oven?

Well, the answer is sort of. Parchment paper, while resilient to heat in a convection oven, undergoes a bit more direct heat in a toaster oven due to it being closer to the heating elements. Toaster ovens don't have the same cabinet capacity as standard ovens, and the heat placed on the paper in such close proximity to the baking sheet presents more of a fire risk.

Why Would You Need to Put Parchment Paper in a Toaster Oven?

Parchment paper serves the role of a non-stick surface when baking in the oven. So, your cookies or other baked goods don't stick to the baking tray and crumble or tear when you pull them away. The greaseproof nature of the baking tray means it doesn't affect the taste or look of the confectioneries.

Another bonus of using parchment paper is that you don't need additional butter or oils to create a non-stick effect, reducing the calories you're baking. So, parchment paper gives you a healthy alternative to traditional baking methods.

Parchment paper is ideal for use in dough-based baking, stopping burn marks and cracking in the baked goods when removing them from the oven. Let's not forget that using parchment paper also makes clean-up a breeze, removing the need to scrape away those crispy remnants of your baking from the oven.

What Are the Risks of Putting Parchment Paper in a Toaster Oven?

Parchment paper is typically fine for use in convection ovens up to temperatures of 420 °F. However, it's not the case for toaster ovens running at these temperatures. The closer proximity of the paper to the heating elements can end up burning this durable material, creating a fire hazard in the home.

It may start to burn when using parchment paper in environments over 420 °F or placing it too close to the heat source. As the air inside the oven gets superheated by the elements, the paper becomes a fire hazard. Since toaster ovens don't have the same airflow capability as convection ovens, the heat can build up around the paper, causing it to burn.

As a result, you risk damage to the bakeware and toaster oven if a burn occurs, and there's a risk a fire could start and spread to the rest of the kitchen, especially if you're not paying attention to the baking process. Not to mention your batch of cookies burns to a crisp, wasting food and ingredients.

Typically, you can reuse parchment paper, but placing it in the toaster oven at high temperatures could result in drying out, tearing, or crumbling. As a result, you have to throw it away and use a new sheet.

How to Safely Use Parchment Paper in the Toaster Oven

Can you put parchment paper in a toaster oven? You can use parchment paper in the toaster oven without bursting into flames, provided you have the right strategy.

Most toaster oven manufacturers claim using parchment paper in the unit is safe. Still, only some of them give you practical advice on the methodology for doing so without risking burning down the kitchen.

So, we'll help you out instead. Follow these safety guidelines, and you shouldn't have any problems with this plastic wrap alternative.

Don't Use Any Oily Foods

One of the biggest benefits of using parchment paper is you don't have to use any additional butter, grease, or oils when baking with it. Cooking foods with high-fat content usually saturates the parchment paper with fat, and oil is a flammable substance, meaning it could catch fire in the toaster oven if it comes in contact with the heating elements.

Cut the Paper Precisely

Parchment paper comes in large sheets; you don't want any excess material hanging outside the direct cooking area. Extra material might come in contact with the heating elements, resulting in it catching fire.

Measure the size of your bakeware and cut out the correct quantity of material for a snug fit. Please don't leave any hanging over the sides where it might contact the heating element. Ensure you correctly measure because if your baked goods reach the tray, they might struggle to remove from the baking tray, resulting in cracking or burning of the confectionery.

Never Reuse the Parchment Paper

While parchment paper is usually suitable for reuse in convection ovens, that's not the case for the toaster oven. Oils and fats from your baked goods will seep into the paper, diminishing its heat resistance and the non-stick characteristic of the paper's coating.

Place the Food on the Lower Tray

A toaster oven has a confined cooking area, resulting in fast superheating of the space. Place the baking tray on the lower tray in the toaster type of oven to keep it as far away from the heating element as possible. Placing the tray in the top position in the toaster oven brings it closer to the heat source, increasing the risk of burning. Using the lower tray might increase the cooking time slightly, but at least you have minimal risk of the paper catching fire.

Are There Any Alternatives to Using Parchment Paper?

Can you put parchment paper in a toaster oven? Yes, but parchment paper isn't the only option for the toaster oven. You have other materials offering the same non-stick properties without the fire risk.

Aluminum Foil

Aluminum foil is capable of handling temperatures beyond the 420 °F threshold, and there's no risk of it catching fire in the toaster oven. You don't have to worry about trimming this material precisely like with parchment paper.

If it's hanging over the tray and contacts the heating element, it won't burn. However, aluminum foil needs a bit of greasing to form a proper non-stick surface, and that adds more calories to the baked goods.

Cooking Spray & Greases for Toaster Ovens

There's a huge range of cooking sprays and oils for use in ovens and other cooking practices. Spraying the tray with some canola or coconut oil is a great idea.

Canola can withstand high temperatures, as can coconut oil. However, ensure you use the extra-virgin variety of coconut oil, and unless you want your baked goods smelling and tasting like coconut, get the unscented version.

Don't use olive oil sprays in the toaster oven or any high-temperature cooking application. Olive oil has a low "smoke point" and will start to burn at high temperatures. Exposing olive oil to high temperatures turns the fats in the spray and the oil rancid, converting fats to trans-saturated fatty acids.

Silicon Oven Pads

Parchment paper contains silicone as the key component providing its non-stick properties. So, a silicone baking mat or tray is a great option for the toaster oven. It's resistant to high temperatures, and there's no chance of the silicone becoming unstable and entering your food.

Silicone baking mats and trays present no fire risk if exposed to high temperatures, and they're washable, dishwasher safe, and reusable. Look for toaster-oven-safe silicone baking trays and mats from trusted brands.

FAQs Regarding Using Parchment Paper in a Toaster Oven

When people ask can you use parchment paper in a toaster oven, a slew of other questions arise. Let’s cover the most common ones now.

Can You Put Parchment Paper in a Convection Oven?

Yes. Parchment paper is entirely safe in a convection oven without presenting the same fire risk as in a toaster-style oven alternative. As long as you keep the temperature inside the oven below 420 °F, you won't have any issues with the parchment paper burning.

Will Parchment Paper Catch Fire in a Toaster Oven?

Yes. Parchment paper can catch fire in a toaster oven if it comes in contact with the heating elements. If you bake fatty foods in the unit, the added grease and oil produced by these foods saturate the paper, and there's a chance it could burn. The risk of fire increases if the saturated paper contacts the heating elements.

Can You Put Wax Paper in a Toaster Oven?

No. Don't use wax paper in the toaster oven. The high temperatures in the toaster oven cause the wax paper to melt, sticking to your food. Wax has a lower smoke point than silicone-based parchment paper and burns at lower temperatures. So, keep wax paper out of the toaster oven for safety's sake.

Key Takeaways Regarding Parchment Paper in a Toaster Oven

• You can use parchment paper in the toaster oven if you're careful with how you use it.
• The silicone-based parchment paper is generally able to withstand the high heat of the toaster oven.
• Don't let the parchment paper contact the heating elements inside the toaster oven. Trim the paper to the correct size before use.
• Don't bake or toast greasy foods on parchment paper in the toaster oven.
• Place the baked goods on the lower tray inside the toaster oven to keep the parchment paper as far away from the heating elements as possible.
• Consider using alternatives like greased aluminum foil or silicone heating mats.

So, Can You Put Parchment Paper in a Toaster Oven?

That’s the question of the hour… can you put parchment paper in a toaster oven? You can, but stay away from fat and oily foods that may drip or catch fire, and don’t exceed 420 °F in temperature. If you can avoid those few concerns, you’ll have no issues.

You'll Also Enjoy:

• Can You Put Aluminum Foil in the Oven?
• Can You Put Ceramic in the Oven? Check the Symbol
• 16 Rolling Pin Substitutes to Get That Dough Flat Now
• How Long Can You Leave a Wax Warmer On?
• 13 Dutch Oven Substitutes: The Hottest Alternatives